Unseen Japan

The Japan You Don't Learn About in Anime.

After all these years, the Japanese government officially recognized the Ainu. Here's why the Ainu can't take them seriously. (Picture: NOBU / PIXTA(ピクスタ))

Why Japan's Ainu Recognition Bill Upsets the Ainu

Essay   Posted on March 18, 2019 in ainu, hokkdaio, indigenous, history, law, equality • By Alyssa Pearl Fusek • Read Related Articles

Help us pay our writers/translators what they're worth, and to translate more great content from Japanese - become a Patron through Patreon today!

Much like the Native Americans of the USA, and the Aborigines of Australia, the Ainu people of Japan have suffered discrimination, forced assimilation, and stringent government policies that threatened to strip them of their cultural heritage and language. Despite measures providing welfare and cultural promotion, the Ainu remain on the edge of obscurity in the public consciousness. In 2014, Sapporo City assemblyman Kaneko Yasuyuki tweeted that the Ainu people "no longer existed.", which prompted an Ainu association to ask when exactly they ceased to exist.

This year the government is trying to bring the Ainu into the spotlight. A draft bill codifying the Ainu as Japan’s "indigenous people" was submitted to the Diet for review on February 5, and later approved by the Cabinet. Experts, professors, economists, and so on lauded how the bill would finally legitimize the Ainu as an indigenous people; that a fight the Ainu had fought for years was finally over.

The Ainu, however, had other things to say. At a press conference for the Foreign Correspondents’ Club of Japan, various Ainu ekashi (the Ainu word for 'elders') decried the vague wording of the bill and the notable absence of indigenous rights. They demanded the government retract the bill from Diet consideration and review it thoroughly.

Ainu leaders bash bill for absence of their aboriginal rights:The Asahi Shimbun
Leaders of Ainu groups from Hokkaido blasted a landmark bill recognizing the Ainu as indigenous peop

Other rights’ groups have questioned the government’s motives behind the bill’s submittal. The Sankei News reported what the bill’s main intention was: to appeal to the world by promoting the Ainu to foreign visitors ahead of the Tokyo Olympics in 2020. Other news outlets reported similar summaries of this bill, leaving the preservation of Ainu culture as an afterthought. That’s nothing new, given Japan’s long history of demeaning and subjugating the Ainu.

(JP) Link: Ainu Support Bill Decided by Cabinet; Declared "Aborigines"

アイヌ支援法案を閣議決定 「先住民族」と明記
政府は15日、アイヌ民族を支援する新法案を閣議決定した。アイヌ民族の地位向上などを目指して「先住民族」と初めて明記し、アイヌ文化の維持・振興のための交付金制度創…

Who Are the Ainu?

A goup of Ainu
A group of Ainu in 1904. If you look close enough you can see tattoos around the mouths of the women; in Ainu culture tattoos were reserved for women only. (Picture: Wikipedia)

Unseen Japan dove a little into the history of the Ainu with Noah Oskow's history of the colonization of Hokkaido. For those who missed it, here's a recap.

The Ainu people trace their beginnings to pre-Jomon period Japan (c. 14,000–300 BCE), though their true genealogical map has still to be determined. The Ainu evolved out of a smattering of Jomon, Satsumon, and Okhotsk cultures. They primarily inhabited the northernmost island of Hokkaido, Sakhalin, and some of the Kuril Islands. The early Ainu were hunter-gatherers, relying on fishing and trade with other small tribes. They worshiped nature and animals, with the bear ranking chief among them. Today their true numbers are unknown, as some Ainu aren’t willing to disclose their ethnic roots, and many Ainu have assimilated so deeply into Japanese society they may lack knowledge of their Ainu roots. Estimates place the population to be between 25,000 and 200,000.

We know that the Ainu and Japanese were familiar to each other as early as the 13th century, but it was in 1456 when accumulated tensions on both side broke out into revolt, now known as Koshamain’s Revolt, after the great Ainu leader Koshamain was killed. This would be only the first of many clashes with Japanese authority. In the Edo period (1601-1868) the two cultures managed to establish economic relations, but unrest continued to threaten the balance.

A History of Discrimination and Abuse

The Meiji Restoration of 1868 boded ill for the Ainu. As writer Jude Isabella so succinctly points out, the Ainu were "an inconvenient culture at a time when the government was steadfastly creating a national myth of homogeneity" (Isabella). Desperate for land and jobs for the recently abolished samurai class, and wanting to prove themselves as worthy equals to the West, the Japanese government promulgated the Hokkaido Indigenous Protection Act (北海道ほっかいどう旧土人きゅうどじん保護法ほごほう) in 1899 as a way to annex Hokkaido. Under the koseki, Japan’s family registry, the Ainu were downgraded to a commoner status, effectively stripping away their rights as an indigenous people. The government rubbed more salt into the wound by prohibiting the Ainu from carrying out their traditional hunting and fishing practices, as well as tattooing. They gave them a bunch of farming tools, land that later turned out to be unsuitable for farming, and left them to figure it out themselves.

The Act wasn’t abolished until 1997, during which the Ainu suffered from social and economic discriminations. Ainu children were singled out and bullied. Ainu faced difficulty securing employment. Out of fear of being discriminated and shamed, many Ainu started to bury their Ainu heritage in favor of fitting in. As many Ainu assimilated into Japanese culture, aspects of their history and traditions were gradually lost.

Keeping Ainu Traditions Alive
An Ainu man is finding ways to preserve the traditional indigenous culture of his people amidst the sprawling urban landscape of modern Japan. Please subscri...

Ainu ekashi Urakawa Haruzo pays respect to the gods and the dead, representing one of many Ainu striving to keep their culture and traditions alive. Some Ainu, like Urakawa, denied their Ainu heritage most of their lives before learning to embrace it.

The 1997 bill didn’t magically wipe away all these experiences. Surveys today still show the Ainu struggling in education and employment. Discrimination hasn’t ceased either. In recent years the battle for recognition as an indigenous people has garnered support from international communities. This bill was the culmination of years of facing pressure from both the Ainu and overseas rights’ groups.

A Problematic Bill

Ainu bear sacrifice
A painting depicting Ainu performing a bear sacrifice, known as iyomante in Ainu and kumaokuri (熊送り) in Japanese. Ainu people possessed more body and facial hair than the Japanese, a fact that only added more fuel to the discriminatory fire. (Picture: Wikipedia)

But does it actually respect the Ainu as an indigenous people?

If the Japanese government was hoping the Ainu would be appeased by this recent bill, they were sorely mistaken. So what exactly does the bill entail, and what does it lack that is upsetting so many Ainu?

For starters, the bill would replace the current 1997 bill and legally recognize the Ainu as an indigenous people. All well and good, right? Not so fast. Nothing in the bill states anything about granting the Ainu indigenous rights. Indigenous rights include the right to self-determination, autonomy, and land rights. The irony is especially biting when we remember that Japan was one of 143 countries who pledged their support to the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples in 2007.

The bill also officially allocates funds for tourism efforts to draw people to Hokkaido where the Ainu people originated. One such plan is to open a National Ainu Museum and Park before 2020. Shimizu Yuji, president of the Kotan no Kai (コタンの会), called out the government for using them as a "tourism resource." And who can blame him? The government has made no secret about their hopes of attracting tourists to Ainu cultural hubs.

In early March a Japan Communist Party (JCP) and a former House of Representatives member met with members from various Ainu associations to ask their thoughts regarding the new bill:

「平取『アイヌ遺骨』を考える会」の木村二三夫共同代表は、強制移住や同化政策の歴史にふれ「政府はアイヌ民族への差別の歴史について、国民の理解を得ることをしていない」と批判。むかわアイヌ協会の三上純会長は「一歩前進」としつつ、「サケ漁が特別措置として盛り込まれたが、現行でも知事に申請すれば可能。新法で何が変わるのか」と疑問を呈しました。 苫小牧アイヌ協会の澤田一憲会長は「貧困の連鎖を断ち切るための乳幼児期から学齢期の経済的支援と無年金・低年金のアイヌ高齢者の年金支給は欠かせない」と語りました。

Kimura Fumio, co-chairman of the Ainu Ikotsu wo Kangaeru Kai, brought up the history of forced emigration and assimilation policy, and the criticism, "The government hasn’t obtained the people’s understanding of the history of discrimination towards the Ainu people." Mikami Jun, president of the Mukawa Ainu Association, conceded that it was a step forward, but also said, "Salmon fishing is included as a special measure, but even now it’s possible to get permission to fish if you request the prefectural governor. What changes with the new law?"

Sawada Kazunori, chairman of the Tomakomai Ainu Association, pointed out, "Economic support for children from their infancy to school age years in order to sever the chain of poverty, as well as providing pensions to Ainu seniors with no or low pensions, are crucial."

(JP) Link: The Proposed "New Ainu Law": Airing Their Opinions

「アイヌ新法」案 当事者の意見反映を/宮本岳志・はたやま氏が懇談/北海道

Sad to say, this bill seems more rooted more in politics and catering to overseas communities than anything else. Touting tourist visitor numbers before talking about preservation of the Ainu ways of life was a bad move by the government. While we’d like to think that government recognition will solve all problems for the Ainu, that’s not realistic. How can any nation redeem itself after centuries of persecuting, degrading, and all but obliterating an indigenous people?

The bill is slated for deliberation in the Diet. The Japanese government would do well to seriously consider the opinions of Ainu ekashi and Ainu associations on revisions and additions to the bill. I say grant them their indigenous rights. The Ainu have waited and suffered long enough.

Sources

Isabella, Jude. "How Japan’s Bear-Worshipping Indigenous Group Fought Its Way to Cultural Relevance." Smithsonian Magazine, Oct 18, 2017. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/how-bear-worshipping-group-in-japan-fought-for-cultural-relevance-180965281/

Alyssa Pearl Fusek is a freelance Japan and mental health content writer living in Chico, California with her partner and one cat. She graduated in 2015 from Willamette University with a B.A. in Japanese Studies and continues to improve her Japanese language skills. She is also a published poet and fiction writer. You can check out her freelance writing work at The Japanese Pearl.

Comments



You May Also Enjoy Reading...

Japanese lighthouse on Sakhalin (a.k.k. Karafuto)

Karafuto: Japan's Lost Prefecture

Essay   By Noah Oskow  ·  April 03, 2019 • Tagged with history, hokkaido, sakhalin, russia, meiji, russo-japanese war, WWII, indigenous, ainu

The story of how, for a brief period of time, an island controlled by Russia became an official part of Japan.

Russia, Japan, and Sakhalin/Karafuto

Sakhalin Island: Japan's Final Frontier

Essay   By Noah Oskow  ·  March 25, 2019 • Tagged with history, hokkaido, sakhalin, tokugawa, russia, meiji, indigenous, ainu

How Japan's discovery of a large northern island devastated the island's native population - and how Japan lost control when Russia muscled in.

Hokkaido

The Colonization of Hokkaido: How a "Foreign" Frontier Became Japan

Essay   By Noah Oskow  ·  February 13, 2019 • Tagged with history, hokkaido, ainu, colonization, meiji era, edo

How a mysterious frontier island peopled by "barbarians" became one of the four main islands of Japan - and how the original inhabitants suffered as a result.

Nagoya castle

Nagoya City Suggests the Disabled Use Drones to Scale a Castle

News   By Jay Andrew Allen  ·  July 10, 2019 • Tagged with equality, technology, disabled, history, politics

When the city of Nagoya announced the renovated Nagoya Castle would lack an elevator for disabled access, the response was...less than uplifting.

Japanese flag and LGBT flag

In Japan, The Surge for Marriage Equality Builds

News   By Jay Andrew Allen  ·  April 18, 2019 • Tagged with law, marriage, lgbt, equality

An uptick in public support has LGBT couples in Japan on the offensive, as a new series of lawsuits aims to turn the legal tide for same sex marriage.